For this image Ganesh, I would go with the monotone
. I love the grains in the color one, was just feeling may be if you could have retained those grains in the monochrome version as well ?? What do you think ? I would have loved the color version equally if the flower petals on the right looked like the one's on the left which has lovely soft muted tones of yellow. But since they lack real colors on them, the monochrome does better justice. These are my thoughts, but I like the details on the caterpillar more in the colored version. Overall considering all points, I think the monochrome wins.