Works well for me except that I see artifacting of the sky, I would prefer a non-centric divide of the horizon. The pattern of the rocks and sheet of water due to long exposure works well. I wonder why we tend to shift the image towards b/w this one would have been impeccable even in color as well.

Good one. As VMR pointed out the processesing does not do justice to the subtle tones in the sky. The smaller rocks at the edge also could have been brought in fully. Well seen

A very nice frame here. Agree to Vijay ji ..

thanks vijay sir , rajkumar sir n ashish sir for your valuable cmnts...
i just kept this one half horizoned as i wanted to portray two states of mind, one as clear as sky and other as turbulent as water sheet below.... but i agree that asthetically image looks better whn horizon is kept in onethird part, i have tht compo too...
artifacts i guess may have come as i reduced the image size too much ..raw looks ok....
i took this pic in early morning on west side..so color pic looks almost similar...